If you're really keen on avoiding disappointment, you could play it safe by pre-ordering Arkane Studio's action/RPG, Dark Messiah of Might and Magic that's available via Steam for $49.95.
Developed by the team behind the RPG Arx Fatalis, this entry in the long-running Might and Magic series brings the legendary RPG to life in new ways with the power of the Source Engine powering its character animation, graphics, AI and real-world physics to provide a wholly immersive first-person RPG experience. The second chapter in the new Might & Magic franchise allows players to experience ferocious combat as an expert warrior, mage, or assassin using a vast array of devastating weapons against vicious creatures in a captivating fantasy environment.
For a better look at the game head on over to our hands-on impressions of the game's single player demo.