Dismissing privacy concerns, a federal judge overseeing a $1 billion copyright-infringement lawsuit against YouTube has ordered the popular online video-sharing service to disclose who watches which video clips and when.
U.S. District Judge Louis L. Stanton authorized full access to the YouTube logs after Viacom Inc. and other copyright holders argued that they needed the data to show whether their copyright-protected videos are more heavily watched than amateur clips.
The data would not be publicly released but disclosed only to the plaintiffs, and it would include less specific identifiers than a user's real name or e-mail address.
Lawyers for Google Inc., which owns YouTube, said producing 12 terabytes of data - equivalent to the text of roughly 12 million books - would be expensive, time-consuming and a threat to users' privacy.
The database includes information on when each video gets played, which can be used to determine how often a clip is viewed. Attached to each entry is each viewer's unique login ID and the Internet Protocol, or IP, address for that viewer's computer.
Stanton ruled this week that the plaintiffs had a legitimate need for the information and that the privacy concerns are speculative.
Stanton rejected a request from the plaintiffs for Google to disclose the source code - the technical secret sauce - powering its market-leading search engine, saying there's no evidence Google manipulated its search algorithms to treat copyright-infringing videos differently.
The court has yet to rule on Google's requests to question comedians Jon Stewart and Stephen Colbert of Viacom's Comedy Central.
Viacom is seeking at least $1 billion in damages from Google, saying YouTube has built a business by using the Internet to "willfully infringe" copyrights on Viacom shows, which include Comedy Central's "The Daily Show with Jon Stewart" and Nickelodeon's "SpongeBob SquarePants" cartoon.
The lawsuit was combined with a similar case filed by a British soccer league and other parties.
Together, the plaintiffs are trying to prove that YouTube has known of copyright infringement and can do more to stop it, a finding that could dissolve the immunity protections that service providers have when they merely host content submitted by their users.
Though Google said giving the plaintiffs access to YouTube viewer data would threaten users' privacy, Stanton referred to Google's own blog entry in which the company argued that the IP address alone cannot identify a specific individual.
In a statement, Google said it was "disappointed the court granted Viacom's overreaching demand for viewing history. We are asking Viacom to respect users' privacy and allow us to anonymize the logs before producing them under the court's order."
Google did not say whether it would appeal the ruling or seek to narrow it.
Stanton's ruling made only passing reference to a 1988 federal law barring the disclosure of specific video materials that subscribers request or obtain.
Kurt Opsahl, a senior staff attorney with the Electronic Frontier Foundation, said Stanton should have considered that law along with constitutional free-speech rights, including a right to read or view materials anonymously.
He said a user's ID can sometimes include identifying information such as a first initial and last name.
Viacom said it isn't seeking any user's identity. The company said any data provided "will be used exclusively for the purpose of proving our case against YouTube and Google (and) will be handled subject to a court protective order and in a highly confidential manner."
This is not the first time Google has fought the disclosure of user information it had been stockpiling. While gathering evidence for a case involving online pornography, the U.S. Justice Department subpoenaed Google and other search engines for lists of search requests made by their users.
After Google resisted, a federal judge ruled that Google was obliged to turn over only a sample of Web addresses in its search index, not the actual search terms requested.
Court Orders YouTube to Give Viacom Video Logs
By: AP
| Jul 04, 2008
| Ads by Google | ||
Viacom wont get too far with this case as "Google" like many top R&D companies in the us plays a big Role in bringing in Top Dollars into the country.
It's seen as a general Trend for the US government to Protect such companies...
Microsoft's Anti-trust Lawsuite was Way bigger than this case could ever dream of becoming.
Ashwin Furtado @ Jul 05, 2008
LATEST NEWS
- Dell Officially Launches Inspiron Mini 9
- Blaupunkt Launches TravelPilot Series in India
- BSNL to Float $9 Billion Mobile Lines Tender
- Samsung Working to Acquire SanDisk
- Web Portal For Teachers Launched by President Patil
- Sony Recalls Laptops For Possible Overheating
- 21.5-inch BenQ LCD Monitor Enters Indian Market
- BlackBerry Thunder is Now Storm
- 8MP LG Camera Phone Could Make October Debut
- SanDisk Launches New High Speed SD Cards
| Ads by Google | ||
RELATED
Hot Searches & Keywords :
AMD
ATI
Acer
Adobe
Apple
Asus
Blackberry
Blizzard
Blu-Ray
Bluetooth
CES 2007
Canon
Capcom
China
Creative
DVD
Dell
E3 2007
E3 2008
EA
Electronic Arts
Facebook
Gears of War
Google
HP
Halo
IBM
ITunes
Intel
Internet
Ipod
LCD
LG
Linux
Logitech
Microsoft
Mobile
Mobile Phone
Mobile Phones
Motorola
Mp3
Myspace
Nintendo
Nokia
Nvidia
PC
PMP
PS2
PS3
PSP
Philips
Reliance Communications
Samsung
Sandisk
Search Engine
Skype
Smartphone
Sony
Sony Ericsson
Toshiba
Ubisoft
Valve
Vista
Voip
Website
Wii
Windows
Windows Mobile
Windows Vista
Xbox 360
Xbox Live
Xbox360
Yahoo!
Youtube
Zune
digicam
digital camera
iPhone
laptop
mp3 player
printer
social networking site
test
yahoo
| Ads by Google | ||
|
|
Sections
Products
Camcorders |
Controllers |
CPUs |
Desktop PCs |
Digital Cameras |
Digital Video Recorders |
DVD Players |
Games |
Gaming Consoles |
General |
GPS Systems |
Handhelds / PDAs |
Hard Drives |
Headphones & Headsets |
HiFi Audio Systems |
Home Theater Systems |
Input Devices |
Internet |
Laptops |
Low Level Components |
Mac Systems |
Mobile Phone Accessories |
Mobile Phones |
Monitors |
Motherboards |
MP3 / Audio Players |
Multi-Function Devices |
Networking |
Optical Drives |
PC Accessories |
PC Add-on Cards |
PC Cabinets |
PC Games |
Printers |
Projectors |
RAM Modules |
Scanners |
Software |
Speakers |
Telecom |
TVs |
Video Players |